What the grade means

The grade from A to F weighs two things: how complete the passport is (60%) and how well it is delivered under the EN standards (40%). But the grade is not what decides whether it may be published — the mandatory fields are.

Publishing is decided by the mandatory fields, not by the grade. A passport may be published when every mandatory field is filled in. The letter follows: a passport that may be published gets at least a C, one that may not gets at most a D.
1
Every mandatory field filled in

The fields the regulation requires for the product's category. If one is missing the passport may not be published, however high the grade.

2
The standards checks, counted in the grade

Whether the passport can be reached and read by machines: EN 18216 access, EN 18219 identifier, EN 18221 versions and backup, EN 18223 header fields. They weigh 40% of the score and decide where the passport lands within its band, but not whether it may be published.

The grades

A
90–100
Everything mandatory, and most of the optional fields and standards checks.
B
75–89
Everything mandatory, with gaps in the optional fields or the standards checks.
C
60–74
Everything mandatory, but little of the optional or weak standards checks.
D
—
Mandatory fields are missing. The passport cannot be published.
F
—
More is missing than is present.

How the score is calculated

Two parts. The fields: mandatory fields carry 70 of 100, optional ones 30, and if a category has only mandatory fields they carry the whole hundred. The standards checks: the share passed. The score is 60% fields and 40% standards checks.

A
All mandatory, all optional
Score 100 · May be published: Yes
A
All mandatory, two thirds optional
Score 94 · May be published: Yes
A
All mandatory, half optional
Score 91 · May be published: Yes
B
All mandatory, no optional
Score 82 · May be published: Yes
D
One mandatory missing, all optional
Score 98 · May be published: No

Example: ESPR Base — 17 mandatory and 47 optional fields, with every standards check passed.

The last row is why the letter is not the answer: a passport can be almost complete and still be missing the one thing that is required.

The two numbers on the result page

Fields

What the passport contains, measured against the category's field list. It weighs 60% of the score and decides whether the passport may be published.

System conformance

How the passport is delivered, not what it contains: address, content negotiation, versions, backup, header fields. Each check points at a clause in an EN standard. It weighs 40% of the score.

What counts as mandatory

It depends on the product. A battery is measured against Annex XIII of the Battery Regulation, a jumper against Article 7 and Annex III of the Ecodesign Regulation. Every field carries the reference to the provision that requires it.

A field is mandatory when a provision requires it. Product name, brand and model number are: the regulation requires the product to be identifiable. Size and colour are required by no provision — they exist so a person recognises their own item, and count as optional.